Computer Science Department, Bucknell University

Assignment 2
Article Reviews
CSCI 475, Fall 1997
Due Wednesday September 10, 1997

Sam, your boss, has asked you to investigate the computational aspects of gene sequencing. After the initial reaction of "BUT I don't know anything about gene sequencing!", you decide to do a literature search to gain a knowledge base.

Purpose of Assignment:

  1. To investigate the information content of DNA and genes. To answer questions such as: What is the genetic code? How is the information encoded? How is it structured? How is it used?

  2. To practice performing a literature search for technical material. Reference: CSCI 475 web page on "How To Do A Literature Search".

  3. To learn how to read technical material critically. Reference: CSCI 475 web page on "How to Read Technical Articles".

  4. To practice writing an article review and perform a credibility analysis.

  5. To start a knowledge base for your team.

The Assignment:

  1. First, read the article handed out in class "Teaching Students to Critically Evaluate the Quality of Internet Research Resources" by Professor Cunningham. Reference: CSCI 475 web page on "Critically Evaluating the Quality of a Research Source".

  2. Find three (3) relevant articles to review. One must be from popular press, e. g., Newsweek, Time or Reader's Digest. One must be from a scholarly journal. One must be an article from the World-Wide Web, say, found by using the altavista search engine. An article can not be one that is already listed on the CSCI 475 Web pages. Reference: CSCI 475 web page on
    " Scholarly Journals Vs. Popular Press".

  3. Write a one to two page review of each article. Read each carefully and write a summary in your own words.

  4. Analyze each article for credibility using Professor Cunnington's criteria. Give an overall rating of credibility for each article.

The assignment must be written on a word processor. Hand in the writeups and a copy of each of the three articles.


Page maintained by Dan Hyde, hyde@bucknell.edu Last update September 2, 1997
Back to Computer Science Department's Home page.