Each of the items below is assigned a numeric value between 1 and 4 that corresponds to the following mapping:

(1) Not satisfactory (2) Marginally satisfactory (3) Satisfactory (4) Above expectations

Content-- 40%

• Provide complete, accurate, and up-to-date information
• Set the proper background and context for the readers to follow
• Support the assessments and conclusions by data, analysis, and evidence.

Mechanics -- 30%

• Use proper language
• Use correct spelling, grammar, punctuation, sentence, and paragraph structure
• Use appropriate headings
• Include sections on introduction, background, core content, conclusion, citations, and references

Effectiveness-- 20%

• Convey the concepts clearly using simple terms and structures
• Present a clear logic flow of the content

Extraordinary Elements 10%

• Contain anything that positively surprises the reader